When You Were Older

Buy book online
Buy book online Buy book online

When You Were Older, Catherine Ryan Hyde, book reviewWhen You were Older is the fabulous new novel by Catherine Ryan Hyde. Set against the backdrop of the 9/11 terrorist attacks, it tells a poignant and moving tale of family and prejudice. I loved this book from the moment that I first picked it up and I hardly wanted it to finish.

Russell Ammiano should have died on September 11th 2001. In fact he would have died had it not been for the phone call that informed him of his mother’s death and the need for him to return home to his home town in Kansas to sort out care for his mentally disabled older brother, Ben. Taking that call prevented him getting to his office in the twin towers for the scheduled 8.30 am meeting. Some might call him lucky but obviously dealing with the death of his mother who he had not seen for six years and finding out what it is like to live with Ben, a creature of habit, on a daily basis is not easy.

Disorientated and confused, Russell attempts to adapt to a new way of life which centres around Ben and his rituals. His only solace is the daily visit to Nazir’s Bakery and especially his chats with Nazir’s daughter Anat. As their friendship blossoms, Russell is very disturbed by the amount of prejudice that is displayed towards her Egyptian family particularly in the wake of 9/11. Then after a local man is killed in the ensuing war, things really take a catastrophic turn for the worst which Russell is devastated to find Ben at the heart of.

I’ll say no more about the story line only that it is brilliant and one that absorbed me all the way through. I think that When You were Older is a beautifully written book that is typical of Catherine Ryan Hyde’s gentle style. She is a wonderful story teller who creates characters that you really start to care about. There were moments when she genuinely surprised me because of the direction of the story and there were others where she had me in tears.

When You were Older is also written in a very interesting way. The first few chapters are set during the days immediately after 9/11 but they go backwards in time starting on the 15th September. This enables the reader to piece together the story in quite an interesting way. The middle part of the book goes back in time about twenty years and provides glimpses of Ben and Russell’s childhood. This is fascinating as one reads the events that led to Ben, previously a typical domineering older brother, becoming disabled and forever having to live with the mind of a child.

I found the relationship between Russell and Ben particularly poignant and couldn’t help but be reminded of Tom Cruise and Dustin Hoffman in ‘Rain Man’. Don’t think that this is an imitation of that story though, as it is much more. When You were Older is particularly moving because of the time it is set. I think that Catherine Ryan Hyde very cleverly demonstrates the unease and mistrust that was abundant in multi-cultural America at that time. This made it a sometimes disturbing read but this also made it compelling.

Overall this is a wonderful book that I wholeheartedly recommend.

When You were Older by Catherine Ryan Hyde
Published by Doubleday, March 29th, 2012
Thanks to Doubleday for providing a review copy.

Buy book online
Buy book online Buy book online
When You Were Older
by Catherine Ryan Hyde

2 Comments on "When You Were Older"

  1. John W. Strobel III
    25/03/2012 at 06:30 Permalink

    Your review of Catherine’s book makes me want to rush out and find a copy to read. As an author I respect Catherine’s unique storytelling abilities, she is a master story teller. As a reader I find I need to expand my world of “to reads” if I am ever to reach her level of writing. Congratulations Catherine on this wonderful review. I will find a copy of “When You Were Older” as soon as I can…JWSIII

  2. Fran
    25/03/2012 at 12:46 Permalink

    I am torn between reading this story and not reading it. My brother should have died in 9/11 but didn’t. I will read it because I love Catherine’s books.

Hi guest, please leave a comment:

Subscribe to Comments
Written by kingfisher

My name is Jo and I have been married to Simon for nine years. We have two beautiful daughters – Rachel who is six and Natalie who is almost five and starting school in January. I also have two step children aged twenty one and seventeen so family life is never dull. I also manage to work three days for a local education authority where I support the teaching of literacy in primary schools. I love my job and it’s ideal for a book lover like me. In my spare time I run, dance and occasionally tread the boards with my local amateur dramatics group. My first love is reading though and you will never find me without a book on the go. My husband is also an avid reader and we are hoping to pass on our love of reading to our daughters. They certainly love their bedtime stories every night. Although I have and English degree and I am familiar with most of the classics, I generally read much lighter stuff these days. It’s mainly ‘chic lit’ but I also enjoy a good thriller or courtroom drama. I have so many favourite authors and this list tends to change regularly depending on what I am reading.

Read more from